PFMEA: A Guide to Preventing Process Failures

When to Use PFMEA?

Conducting PFMEA allows teams to prepare and build process safeguards that’ll reduce or prevent the occurrence of operational downtime, injury or accident, costly repairs, and reworks in the business.

PFMEA is conducted when the following occurs in the organization:

• New changes are made on existing processes
• New technology, equipment, or process steps are being introduced
• Implementing a process to a new facility, or department

Benefits

Integrating PFMEA in process improvement initiatives offers several advantages, including:

• Prevention of failure –: PFMEA helps identify potential failures before they happen, allowing organizations to take proactive measures to minimize their occurrence, if not eliminate them.
• Improved process reliability -Promoting process correction, prevention, or redesign allows organizations to monitor critical parameters and develop effective control plans. This leads to enhanced process efficiency and reduced waste.
• Enhanced quality – By focusing on preventing process-related issues, PFMEA leads to higher product and service quality, reducing defects and rework.
• Cost savings – Preventing failures and improving process efficiency can significantly reduce costs associated with downtime, scrap, rework, and warranty claims.
• Increased customer satisfaction – Delivering higher quality products and services with fewer defects increases customer satisfaction and trust.

How to Conduct PFMEA in 7 Steps

Conducting Process FMEA can be summarized into 7 steps, which are as follows:

Step 1: Review Processes

When starting PFMEA, it is important to first determine the focus of your evaluation. Is it a business process? A service process? Or a production process? Once you’ve determined what area you want to focus on, start reviewing the steps associated with it and determine what each step intends to accomplish. One of the best ways to do this is putting it on a flowchart for better visualization.

Step 2: Identify Potential Failure Modes

What could possibly go wrong in the step? Potential failure modes are scenarios that may derail the process from the intended outcome. For example, in a manufacturing company, it is quite common to use machineries like pallet conveyors for moving products as part of the production process. A potential failure mode for that process could be that boxes or bottles may slip, dash, or get damaged as they travel along the conveyor.

Step 3: List Potential Failure Effects & Assign Severity Score

What could be the result if the identified potential failure occurs? Consider its impact on the customers, workers (e.g. injury), environment, facility, and even the process itself. There may be more than one, so list them all down and try to be as detailed as possible. When that’s done, rate its severity with 1 being the lowest and 10 as the highest. Severity ratings are based on how serious the consequences are.

Step 4: Determine Potential Causes & Assign Occurrence Rating

What could trigger the potential failure mode? Determine the possible causes and trigger(s) for the failure mode effect to occur. For example, using the same situation mentioned in step 2. If an employee injury occurs due to the identified failure mode, how might that occur? Is it because the employees weren’t wearing the appropriate PPE or is it due to machinery malfunction? Once that’s determined, assign the appropriate rating for occurrence with 1 being the lowest and 10 as the highest. Occurrence ratings are based on how frequently the trigger or cause is likely to occur.

Step 5: Determine Current Process Controls & Assign Detection Rating

Are there existing controls that prevent or detect the failure mode from occurring? Ideally, process steps will have safeguards in place. Write down any related controls and assign detection rating to each, with 1 being the lowest and 10 as the highest. Detection ratings are based on how easily the failure mode will be detected using the current controls.

Step 6: Calculate RPN & Create Actions

In calculating RPN, a process is evaluated and assigned a score on a scale of 1 – 10 and then multiplied to each other. The Risk Priority Number (RPN) will help determine teams which risks to prioritize and create corrective actions. Should the failure mode result in a high RPN, an action plan is created for either corrective measures or improvements. The action plan consists of a detailed instruction or lists of steps to take, assigned personnel to do them, and the target date of when it should be completed.

Step 7: Re-Calculate RPN

After the completion of the action plan, the PFMEA should be re-evaluated by re-calculating the RPN to measure its impact.

PFMEA Example in Manufacturing

To better understand the steps of conducting PFMEA, below is an example that illustrates the PFMEA process in action in the manufacturing industry.

In this example, a food manufacturing company evaluates the process steps in the production of their food products. All steps associated with the process are then listed down. For this example, we’ll focus on one process step:

Using this process step, the next actions involve: identifying potential failure modes, listing potential failure effects, assigning severity score, determining potential causes, assigning occurrence rating, determining current process controls, and assigning detection rating. Below is a table depicting all these actions:

*SEV – severity score; OCC – occurrence rating; DET – detection rating.

Once all this information is laid out, RPN is then calculated for all the process steps to determine which are the most pressing risks to address. For failure modes resulting in a high RPN, an action plan is devised consisting of detailed instructions or lists of steps for either corrective or improvement purposes. Later on, the RPN is re-calculated to measure the impact of the implemented action plan.

Continuously Improve Processes with PFMEA

Processes are a set of actions and steps taken in order to achieve the desired result. It serves as our foundation in all the things we do to achieve our goals. Processes ensure that all steps and actions taken are done in the right way and right time, making it easy to navigate towards the desired outcome. Moreover, it also affects the safety and quality of products and the people involved in it.

In a 2019 industry profile in the United States, the manufacturing industry was considered as one of the top 10 dangerous industries. Injuries and accidents reported commonly occur in the production process. In another report from HSE, statistics showed that most of the injuries in manufacturing are caused by coming into contact with objects or machinery, and slip, trip, or fall.

These reports prove just how critical it is for industries to be conscious of the processes they’ve laid down. To prevent business mishaps and to protect workers, processes should be guided by industry standards and best practices. Organizations can also create their own standards and best practices based on their own evaluation and analysis of processes through use of tools like PFMEA.